After a dog attack, you need to focus on your recovery and not on defending your actions to an insurance company or an angry pet owner. When an owner claims you provoked their animal, they are likely trying to shift the blame to avoid paying for your medical bills and trauma. Understanding your rights can help you push back against these unfair accusations.
Strict liability rule for dog bites
In California, dog owners remain responsible for bite injuries regardless of whether the dog has ever acted aggressively in the past. You do not need to prove the owner was careless or knew the dog was dangerous to pursue a case. Strict liability places a heavy burden on the owner to ensure their animals do not harm anyone in public or lawful private spaces.
Owners, however, are legally allowed to argue that the victim’s own behavior caused the bite. If an owner successfully proves provocation, a court might reduce your compensation or deny your claim entirely.
The state follows “pure comparative negligence” rules, which means you can still receive compensation even if you partially provoked the dog, but your award may decrease by your percentage of fault.
Actions that qualify as provocation
Provocation involves conduct that would cause a typical dog to react with aggression. Common examples that might impact a legal claim include:
- Physically striking, kicking or throwing objects at the dog
- Cornering an animal or pulling its tail, ears or fur
- Intentionally teasing or tormenting the dog with food or toys
- Entering a property illegally to threaten the dog or its owner
Accidental movements usually do not meet the legal standard for provocation. If you accidentally step on a dog’s paw or startle a sleeping animal, the law often still protects you.
Children under 5 years old generally cannot legally “provoke” a dog because courts recognize they lack the capacity to understand the consequences of their actions around animals.
Defending against provocation claims
When a dog owner claims you provoked their animal, you need to gather evidence that contradicts their assertion. This includes:
- Photographs of the location and your injuries
- Medical records documenting bite severity and location
- Statements about your physical position and actions before the bite
- Witness testimony about the dog’s behavior prior to the attack
- Animal control records showing previous aggressive incidents
- Expert testimony about typical dog behavior
Insurance adjusters often use provocation as a tactic to offer lower settlements. They want you to believe you have no case so you will walk away. Enlisting professional guidance early in your case is vital in proving the owner is at fault and securing the compensation you need to recover.
Follow us on Facebook to get the latest news and updates from Spencer and Associates.
